Family violence charges are always serious, but when substance abuse is involved, the situation can become even more complicated. In Texas, assault family violence cases frequently intersect with issues of alcohol or drug abuse, which can escalate conflicts, impair judgment, and lead to dangerous situations.
On This Page
For individuals facing these charges, understanding how substance use may influence the case is critical. Lisa Shapiro Strauss, a seasoned Houston assault family violence lawyer, has years of experience defending clients in domestic violence cases, particularly those complicated by substance abuse. In this post, we’ll explore how substance use can impact these cases and why expert legal representation is vital to securing the best possible outcome.
The Legal Impact of Substance Abuse on Family Violence Cases
In Texas, substance abuse can significantly affect the outcome of family violence cases. Drugs and alcohol often impair judgment and increase aggression, which can escalate situations. When substance use is involved, courts typically impose harsher penalties and stricter bail conditions.
Here’s how substance abuse could impact your case:
Substance Abuse as an Aggravating Factor
Texas courts consider alcohol or drug use as an aggravating factor in domestic violence cases. This means that substance use can lead to more severe charges and harsher penalties. For example, a misdemeanor assault could become a felony if substance abuse was a key factor in the incident.
Even if you have no prior criminal record, substance abuse during the incident can result in longer jail sentences or mandatory rehabilitation programs. Courts can view this behavior as reckless, seeing it as an increased risk to family members.
Harsher Penalties and Sentencing Enhancements
Substance abuse during a family violence incident can lead to stricter penalties. Courts may increase jail time, fines, and impose more restrictive probation conditions, such as mandatory sobriety checks or regular drug testing. For repeat offenders or those with a history of substance abuse, the penalties are even tougher.
Impact on Bail and Restraining Orders
Substance abuse can affect decisions early in the case, such as bail and protective orders. Judges may deny bail for fear the defendant could reoffend. If bail is granted, strict conditions like sobriety checks, drug testing, and restrictions on movement or contacts are often enforced.
Protective orders in these cases are also stricter. The defendant may be prohibited from using drugs or alcohol, and violations — like failing a sobriety test — can lead to immediate jail time or additional charges.
Challenges in Plea Deals and Negotiations
Substance abuse complicates plea negotiations. Prosecutors may argue that it increases the risk of reoffending, making them less likely to offer reduced charges or alternative sentencing.
However, a skilled defense attorney can use substance abuse as a mitigating factor. Showing that the defendant is in treatment or addressing the root cause may help negotiate alternative sentencing, like rehabilitation programs or counseling, instead of jail time.
Impact on Child Custody and Family Court Matters
Substance abuse can affect child custody and visitation rights in family violence cases. Courts prioritize children’s safety, so a parent with a history of substance abuse may face restricted custody or supervised visits.
However, showing commitment to recovery — such as completing court-ordered rehab — may help the parent regain some custody rights. Failing to address substance abuse could lead to long-term or permanent loss of custody.
Long-Term Legal Consequences
A conviction for family violence involving substance abuse can have lasting effects. It may impact employment, housing, and professional licenses. Repeat offenses can result in mandatory prison time and further loss of legal and personal rights.
Defending Against Family Violence Charges Involving Substance Abuse
Defending family violence charges is challenging, and substance abuse raises the stakes even more. If you’re facing charges tied to substance abuse, it’s critical to have an attorney who understands these complexities and can craft a defense that addresses both the substance abuse issue and the charges to achieve the best outcome.
Challenging the Reliability of Witness Testimony
In cases involving substance abuse, witness testimony may be unreliable. Alcohol and drugs can impair memory and judgment, making it harder for witnesses to provide accurate accounts. If the alleged victim or witnesses were intoxicated during the incident, their testimony could be inconsistent, creating reasonable doubt.
Substance use may also lead witnesses to misinterpret the defendant’s actions, especially in emotionally charged situations. The defense can argue that their recollections are biased or incomplete due to their impaired state.
Establishing a Lack of Intent
In Texas, assault family violence charges usually require proof of intent or reckless behavior. However, when alcohol or drugs are involved, the defendant’s ability to form intent may be impaired. A defense attorney can argue that substance abuse affected the defendant’s judgment, making it difficult to form intent.
Though voluntary intoxication is not a full defense under Texas law, it can help reduce the severity of charges. If substance use unintentionally escalated the situation, penalties could be reduced, or alternative sentencing like rehab may be considered.
Pursuing Alternative Sentencing and Rehabilitation
If substance abuse is a factor in your family violence charges, alternative sentencing may be an option. Texas courts often recognize the link between substance abuse and violent behavior and may allow treatment and rehabilitation instead of jail time.
An experienced attorney can negotiate alternatives like drug or alcohol treatment programs, anger management classes, or counseling. These programs address the root cause of the behavior and may reduce charges or lead to case dismissal upon completion.
Defending Against Enhanced Penalties
Substance abuse in family violence cases can lead to enhanced penalties, especially if there are prior convictions or serious harm to the victim. These penalties may include longer jail time, higher fines, and mandatory substance abuse programs.
To minimize these penalties, the defense can present evidence of the defendant’s commitment to recovery, such as enrolling in rehab or therapy. Addressing substance abuse can serve as a mitigating factor, showing the court that steps are being taken to prevent future incidents.
Lisa Shapiro Strauss: A Proven Advocate in Complex Cases
With years of experience defending clients in Houston, Lisa Shapiro Strauss has built a reputation as a compassionate and highly skilled criminal defense attorney. She understands the challenges of defending family violence cases involving substance abuse and tailors her approach to each client’s specific situation. Whether it’s challenging evidence, negotiating for reduced charges, or advocating for treatment over incarceration, Lisa is committed to securing the best possible outcome for her clients.
Her comprehensive understanding of both criminal law and substance abuse issues enables her to provide holistic representation that considers not just the immediate legal challenges, but also the long-term well-being of her clients. If you or a loved one are facing family violence charges complicated by substance abuse, having an experienced attorney on your side can make all the difference in your case.
Contact Lisa Shapiro Strauss today for a confidential consultation. Let her help you protect your rights, fight for a fair outcome, and take steps toward a better future.
